Privatization Planned For Pre-Renewed Pershing Square?

A little bird whispers that Jose Huizar’s non-profit Pershing Square Renew intends to turn the south side of Pershing Square over to something called “Urban Spaces,” which will stock it with dozens of food kiosks. 

Is this true? And if so, will Parks & Rec allow L.A.’s oldest public park to be turned into privatized, commercial space? 

Pershing Square Project Pays Off Big For MacFarlane Partners

Step one: donate a small sum to support downtown LA councilman Jose Huizar's pet project, a high-tech redesign of Pershing Square (ignoring public sentiment that favors a restoration of John Parkinson's 1910 plan). 

Step two: City of Los Angeles grants your company a $1.2 Billion development deal on a former CRA site.

#itsnotaboutthepark 

Notes from the Pershing Square Renew redesign presentation

At tonight's Pershing Square redesign presentation Q&A, two people who use the park regularly made it clear that they REALLY do not like the Great Lawn, prefer a diagonal path for walking through. (In other words, John Parkinson's 1910 design.)

See some new renderings here.

Additional items of note from the presentation and Q&A:

• Shifting LED light show on top of the electronic pergola has been moved to the Olive Street side, beneath the windows of the Biltmore Hotel. Illumination is important to the design team's aim to make the park usable 24 hours a day. Why the move to block the park's most iconic architectural vista? Because now that preliminary engineering surveying is being done, the "winning" (by private jury) design is un-buildable. They said the only places they believe they can peel away the parking lot roof to create wells to plant large trees in is the Hill Street side, opposite the only modern, undistinguished building on the square. Also, we wonder what the Biltmore thinks about a bright LED art installation under its guest's windows?

• Richard Schave​ of the Pershing Square Restoration Society asked about the bump out for Metro that’s beneath the street—how, if at all, will this be integrated in the redesign? Not at all, is the answer.

• Courtland Jindra​ of the Pershing Square Restoration Society asked about the place of the historic memorials and monuments in the proposed redesign. The answer is that these landmarks are important and are to stay—somewhere. But these are not seen in any renderings, and the park’s design is taking shape without any dedicated place for them. We will continue to advocate for the preservation of the monuments and their return to their historic locations throughout the park.

• Kim Cooper​ of the Pershing Square Restoration Society clarified a design team statement about when the park's elevation was altered to block the interior off from sidewalk viewers--this only happened with the Legoretta + Olin plan in 1994, not in the 1950s.

• A citizen wants to know how this is going to be paid for. Nebulous private $ hinted at. There is enough money in donated and Quimby funds to continue working on the design through the generation of a design budget.

• A citizen is concerned about a rumor that a level of parking will be lost in the remodel. This is denied.

• Last question: how are you going to make this place safe from dangerous people? No answer from the presenters—they are looking at design, not daily function of the space.

The Wreaths in the Park

Most people that go to Pershing Square today ignore the various monuments and memorials.  From my own experience many people are not even aware they are there.  Despite this blog and a few other articles here and there, the pieces have been forgotten by city residents.  Unfortunately this is not even exclusive to Pershing Square, as memorials of all types dot southern California with little fanfare. 

However, there was a time when this was not the case with regards to our park between Hill and Olive. One of the most fascinating stories I have come across in the archives of the Los Angeles Times is that of the "Wreaths in the Park."”
 

On April 27th, 1960, just as the clock was about to strike noon, four huge floral arrangements reaching more than six feet in height were placed in Pershing Square. They were set before the 7th California Infantry Spanish American War Memorial, the cannon from the USS Constitution, the Beethoven statue (which also honored William Andrews Clark, founder of the LA Phil), and Doughboy saluting the veterans of World War One. 

Crowds gawked at these tributes, and the question on everyone's lips was "Why?"  All that was left by each wreath was a simple card containing the text "With Sympathy."  Stories filtered around of an elderly Asian man who was present when the flowers were delivered and bowed to each memorial before strolling away happily.  

This was obviously a heckuva story.  The Times quickly located the florist who had delivered the flowers and learned they were ordered by Cheong Wong, an 88-year-old who resided on Bellevue Avenue in Angeleno Heights, overlooking the Hollywood Freeway.  He did not speak English so the newspaper sent a reporter who spoke Chinese to interview him.  When found, Mr. Wong professed to being a mute through an improvised sign language.  Standing barefoot while biting a handkerchief in his lips he provided a card printed with the West Point motto "Duty, Honor, Country."   As the Times would write, "a devilish merriment" was in his eyes.

"It was his secret, this floral beauty he'd brought to the city, and he was keeping it to himself."

I try not to interject too much of myself in these posts, but I nearly always stop and read plaques and stare at statues when I pass by them.  I often wonder how few people do this, versus the majority that almost never take the time to pause and ruminate on the reason that something was immortalized in this way.  While such tributes seek to honor people, places, or things it is really the visitors  pondering their significance who honor history and give a memorial continued life and meaning.  Anyone who admires the statue of Beethoven in Pershing Square, then looks up who Mr. Clark was validates the memorial’s placement.  Someone who looks at all the countries where Americans served on the reverse of Doughboy can appreciate the tremendous sacrifice this monument represents.  That is why what Mr. Wong did over half a century ago moves me today, and why I want to document and restore what I can.  In this way, we can afford our past the respect it deserves.
___
COURTLAND JINDRA is an amateur historian and volunteer for the United States World War I Centennial Commission.  His "Great War" interest is largely focused on America's contribution to and remembrance of it.  Delving into Los Angeles Times' archives, Jindra has located numerous memorials to the war in L.A. County, the first of which being the renaming of "Central Park" as "Pershing Square" in November 1918. He is a passionate advocate for highlighting their importance, and through them the war effort writ large.